Table of Contents
Widely found in nature, poplars and cottonwoods are slender, fast-growing species that belong to the same genus, Populus. Both also have similar habitats and uses, so what is the difference?
In this blog post, we’ll cover everything from their leaves to their fruit so you have all you need to tell them apart.
We’ll also share a little bit about the genus Populus and its economic and ecological importance in our lives.
Key Takeaways
Both poplar and cottonwood are members of the genus Populus.
People confuse them because they both have tall, light-colored barks and produce cotton fluff from their catkins.
Poplars have oval or lobed leaves with different textured undersides and diamond-shaped markings on their barks.
Cottonwoods are taller in size and have oval or heart-shaped leaves and flat ridges on their barks.
Both trees can be used for wood products, landscape ornaments, stabilizing the soil, and carbon sequestration.
Poplar vs Cottonwood: Introduction to These Fast-Growing Trees
Poplar and cottonwood are similar trees that are ubiquitous in North America. Their fast-growing nature makes them a popular choice for both industrial production and landscaping ornaments.
Although they’re under the same genus, cottonwoods have their own sub-genera called Aigeros due to their larger size and different characteristics.
Overview of Poplar and Cottonwood Trees
As members of the genus Populus, poplars and cottonwoods have distinctively tall, slender trunks with shady foliage. Since we humans started to establish plantations, poplars and cottonwoods have been important commodities.
Importance in Ecosystems and Human Use
Thanks to their rapid growth rate, poplars and cottonwoods are excellent for efficient wood production to make timber, fibre, and pulp. They can also protect the environment from flooding, wind, and soil erosion, which is why we use them for windbreaks in agricultural production and landscaping.
Common Confusion Between the Two
The two trees are hard to distinguish because they have similar characteristics due to being under the same genus.
For example, both produce fluff from their catkins in the summertime, so you might think they’re the same trees. Both also look similar at a glance because they have light-colored, tall, and straight trunks.
Explanation of Subgenera
The genus Populus has several sub-genera, which are based on their similarities in habitat, distribution, and physical characteristics. Cottonwoods belong to a separate sub-genera called Aigeiros. These are the sub-genera for Populus genus:
Abaso or Mexican poplars
Turanga or Afro-Asian people
Leucoides or swamp poplars
Tacamahaca or balsam popcorns
Aigeiros or cottonwoods
and Populus or aspens
Physical Differences Between Poplar and Cottonwood Trees
Despite their similarities, there are some easy ways to differentiate between poplars and cottonwood. Pay attention to their leaves, bark, and fruit, and you can easily spot one without confusing it with the other.
Poplar vs Cottonwood Leaves
Poplars and cottonwood have slightly different leaf characteristics. While cottonwood trees have slightly simpler shapes, some poplars may have lobed leaves. See more of their differences below.
Characteristics | Poplars | Cottonwoods |
Shape and Size | Oval or lobed | Oval or heart-shaped |
Margins and Textures | Coarse edges with textured undersides | Coarsely toothed with a shiny texture |
Seasonal Colour Changes | Green to bright yellow | Green to bright yellow or orange |
Shape and Size Differences
Poplar leaves can be oval or lobed like maples, with sizes around 3 inches in length. Cottonwood leaves can be oval or heart-shaped, with sizes ranging between 4 and 10 inches.
Leaf Margins and Textures
Poplars have coarse edges, often with different textured undersides. On the other hand, the leaf margins of cottonwood are coarsely toothed with shiny textures.
Seasonal Colour Changes
Both trees are deciduous, which means they change their leaf colours in the autumn and shed in the winter. Most poplar leaves change into bright yellow, while cottonwood may have orange leaves.
Poplar vs Cottonwood Bark
Characteristics | Poplars | Cottonwoods |
Coloration and texture | Dirty white with shades of grey or gray-green and diamond-shaped lenticels | Smooth and yellow-green bark with flat markings |
One of the easiest ways to identify the two trees is by looking at their barks, because younger versions of cottonwoods and poplar have different markings.
You can read out the full guide on identifying poplar trees in another guide.
Hybrid Poplar Tree
$89.95
$109.99
Hybrid Poplar Tree: The Fast-Growing Privacy Solution Growing an incredible 5-8 feet per year, the Hybrid Poplar Tree matures much faster than other trees, creating a dense, living screen that provides privacy and shade in record time. While other trees… View Product
Coloration and Texture
The bark of poplars can be creamy or dirty white with various shades of grey or gray-green and diamond-shaped black lenticels. Cottonwoods have smooth and yellow-green bark with flat markings.
Ageing Characteristics
Both trees change their bark when they age into darker grey or brown. The texture is rough with numerous fissures and burrs.
Poplar vs Cottonwood Fruit
In late spring or early summer, poplar and cottonwood trees will produce catkins or fruits that will disperse fluffy, cotton-like seeds. The fruits of poplar and cottonwood may differ in colour and number. Cottonwood’s fruits have tan to red colorings, while poplars are mainly red.
Characteristics | Poplars | Cottonwoods |
Fruits | Red catkins | Tan to red catkins, larger |
Description of Seed Dispersal Methods
Poplars and cottonwood are dioecious; each tree has only male or female reproductive organs. The female trees will have capsules that release cotton-like fibres that contain seeds, which will allow the wind to carry them to reach the male trees for pollination.
Does Cotton Come from Poplar Trees?
No, cotton does not come from pine trees. Although poplars produce cotton fleece in the summer, the cotton we use for fabric comes from the genus Gossypium. There's ongoing research where they propose the use of poplar cellulose to replace cotton, but it's not mass-produced yet.
Growth Habits and Environmental Preferences
Cottonwood and poplar have rapid growth rates and similar environmental preferences. See below for more on their sizes and habitats.
If you want to learn about planting, watering, and fertilizing, you can read our complete guide on caring for poplar trees.
Characteristics | Poplars | Cottonwoods |
Growth rate and sizes | Can grow 3 to 5 feet annually; maximum trunk size is 100 feet high and 6 feet wide | Can grow up to 5 feet annually; maximum trunk size is 150 feet high and 10 feet wide |
Lifespan | 20-50 years | up to 200 years |
Preferred Habitat | Moist environment, along bodies of water | Moist environment, along bodies of water |
Geographic distributions | Native to North America, now grown globally | Most are native to European and Asian countries; now grown globally |
Growth Rates and Sizes
Both have considerably fast growth rates, but cottonwoods can reach bigger sizes compared to poplars. The average growth rate of cottonwoods is around 5 ft annually, while poplars grow around 3 to 5 ft annually. Cottonwoods also potentially live longer than poplars.
Average Heights and Widths
Cottonwoods are comparatively larger than other Populus trees, and their trunks can reach up to over 150 feet high and 10 feet wide. In comparison, most poplar trees grow to about 100 feet high and 6 feet wide.
Lifespans
All Populus trees have relatively short lifespans, especially when they grow in non-native areas. Their softwoods are susceptible to numerous damaging agents, such as pests and diseases. On average, poplars live to about 20 to 50 years, while cottonwoods can live up to 200 years with proper care and regular maintenance.
Preferred Habitats
Cottonwoods and most poplars thrive in full sun and are intolerant to shade.
Soil Types
Poplars prefer to grow in moist environments, with soil consisting of river sediment and organic matter or well-drained sandy soils. Cottonwoods naturally occur along bodies of water, such as streams, rivers, and floodplains, but they can also be found on sandy or rocky sites.
Their best environment is moist, well-drained fine sand, but it’s versatile enough that it can live on infertile clays.
Climate Zones
Cottonwoods can grow in most environments but prefer zones 2 through 9. Poplars can also adapt to most environments, with ideal regions being zones 3 to 9.
Geographic Distribution
Both trees have different origins. Cottonwoods are native to the North American landscape, while most poplars are native to Eurasian countries.
Native Regions
The eastern cottonwood is native to North America and grows throughout the US and Canada. Most poplar species, such as white poplar and black poplar, are native to Europe and Asia, but there are also native North American species, such as balsam poplar.
Introduced Areas
Eastern cottonwoods were brought to European and Asian countries, while non-native palms were introduced and naturalised globally.
Hybrid Poplar Tree
$89.95
$109.99
Hybrid Poplar Tree: The Fast-Growing Privacy Solution Growing an incredible 5-8 feet per year, the Hybrid Poplar Tree matures much faster than other trees, creating a dense, living screen that provides privacy and shade in record time. While other trees… View Product
Uses of Poplar and Cottonwood Trees
If there’s anything the two trees have in common, it's that both have important roles in the economy and environment.
Landscaping and Ornamental Uses
Populus trees are known to be easy to grow and can fill up landscapes rapidly, so they’re the perfect addition to public and private spaces.
Windbreaks and Shade Trees
Several popular varieties have thick, columnar foliage, so they’re used as windbreaks that protect the surrounding area by slowing the wind. Cottonwoods and poplars can also be used to provide shade in public areas such as walkways.
Environmental Benefits
Aside from their aesthetic and economic values, poplars and cottonwoods provide environmental benefits by reducing carbon pollution and stabilising riparian zones.
Carbon Sequestration
Both trees can help by reducing carbon in the air and the soil. Their fast-growing nature means they mature early and can absorb more CO2 from the atmosphere.
Riparian Zone Stabilisation
Both trees prefer to grow in riparian zones, which are areas that occur along the edges of rivers, streams, or other bodies of water. Cottonwoods and poplars have a role in stabilising the area and preventing erosion and landslides.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Difference Between Cottonwood and Poplar?
They differ in terms of physical appearance, environmental preferences, growth habits, and uses.
Does Cotton Come from Poplar Trees?
No, the cotton fibre we normally use for fabrics comes from the seed hair fibre of several species from the genus Gossypium. There are studies analysing the possibilities of using poplar fluff as a substitute, but currently the main producing plant for cotton is still the genus Gossypium.
Poplar vs. Cottonwood Leaves: How Can You Tell Them Apart?
Poplar leaves are oval or lobed, while cottonwood leaves are oval or heart-shaped. Some poplars may also have different textures on the underside of their leaves, while cottonwoods don’t.
Poplar vs. Cottonwood Fruit: What Are the Differences?
Cottonwoods are larger, and the colours of cottonwood fruits are tan to red while poplars’ are red.
Are Cottonwoods a Type of Poplar?
Yes, because Cottonwoods are a type of tree under the genus Populus or Poplar.
Final Take: Poplar vs Cottonwood
Although they look similar, poplar and cottonwood are two different species from the same genus. Now that you know some key differences in their leaves or bark, go on a hike and see if you can find both species!
